Tomorrow evening (7/13) at 5 p.m., the Buffalo Common Council will hold a public hearing on the Canal Side project. If you're a supporter, you should think about getting down to Council Chambers in City Hall to attend. Personally, I've sat through and presented before an awful lot of Buffalo Common Council public hearings, and I've generally found that they're going to do whatever they want anyway - but in their defense, the hearings are usually underattended (chicken-or-egg scenario?!). Which is why it's important to flood the microphone with supporters of the project. If the media picks up the vast community support, it'll make it much more difficult for the Common Council members to stall the project.
I like to look at the two big region-altering projects we have on the docket right now - the Peace Bridge and Canal Side. For our community's purposes, the Peace Bridge and adjacent plaza are not necessarily in our hands. It's a bi-national project that needs federal funding that has not yet been identified, environmental impacts have to be completed (they will be soon - we'll be having a different conversation about this in a few months) and despite the fact that it is, indeed, moving along, it is bigger than all of us. The White House and Congress need to make the Peace Bridge Expansion Project a priority, and then it will happen.
Canal Side's scenario is a little different. We control its fate, and much of it is in the hands of the Common Council. The funding has been identified, work is already being done and there is momentum. If Canal Side doesn't happen, it's our own failure as a community for bowing to the vocal minority. The project's supporters need to make sure that doesn't happen.
One of the things currently standing in the way is the proposal that Canal Side sign a Community Benefits Agreement (CBA), in which it would agree to various stipulations, among them a minimum wage rate - called the "living wage" - for anyone doing business on or in the development. Buffalo's living wage rate is $10.53/hr with benefits. If this agreement is signed, every person working for any company at Canal Side will have to make that minimum salary - every restaurant, retail shop or snack stand will have to abide by those rules.
Yes, you're right - it's ridiculous. What companies are going to locate at Canal Side under that expensive mandate? Either that or it's "Hey, want to go down to the waterfront for a $21 burger?" The backers of this proposal would prefer to kill the project before it starts, and while they would be able to claim political victory (Yay!) if the Common Council holds out, it'd really be a shame for the other 1.4 million people in the Buffalo Niagara region. Their contention is that state incentives should not be creating jobs that aren't "quality" jobs. I did a quick poll here at the Partnership of my professional colleagues and found that 9 out of 10 people here began their careers in retail, most of them making very little (I personally made $3.40/hr in my first job - McDonald's when it was on Hertel Avenue - in 1989). Regardless of how the Canal Side obstructionists feel about service jobs - the workforce needs them. There has to be a career level for unskilled workers to give them the opportunity and experience to rise to higher levels. At $10.53 per hour, unskilled workers that would or could be perceived as not being worth that wage, will not get the chance to have those jobs they need to build their careers.
(I make this point all the time in living wage debates - what employer is going to give someone who's capable of doing an $8/hr job a wage of $10.53/hr because they're forced to? No, they're going to not hire that person and instead find someone else who is
worth that wage. Imposing a living wage actually hurts the people it's supposed to be helping!).Like it or not, retail will be a part of Canal Side. Again, it is a region-changing project, one that our residents have been wanting for decades. It will open up our waterfront that has been the poster child for Buffalo's decline, and make it useable and enjoyable for our own residents and visitors.
Interestingly, the state and federal governments are looking to make about $1 billion (yes, that's billion) in investments in the City of Buffalo between Canal Side and the Peace Bridge and the Common Council has a say in all of it. This city has been waiting a long time for some good, job-creating economic development action, and we're on the cusp of getting it. I hope that the Council members understand the gravity of the situation - there is too much at stake for them to stand in the way of moving this city forward at the behest of token but outspoken special interest groups.
If you can get to the public hearing tomorrow evening to say a few words (or a lot of words) about how important this project is to you and to Buffalo, it'd be worth the trip. The opposition will be there (probably rallying), and they usually get press despite a lack of numbers. It is imperative that the people who want to see Buffalo progress show up in greater numbers and drown out the obstructionist voice. Give the Common Council members something to think about.